A psychological therapy that encourages people to engage with the voices they hear, rather than simply attempting to eliminate them, has produced significant improvements in personal recovery, according to a major new study published in The Lancet Psychiatry.
The randomised controlled trial, published on November 10 involved 309 participants experiencing persistent and distressing voices. Researchers found that those receiving Talking with Voices (TwV) therapy alongside usual psychiatric care reported significantly better recovery outcomes than those receiving usual care alone.
Participants also experienced reductions in the severity and distress associated with their voices, improvements in their relationships with voices, fewer negative beliefs about themselves and reductions in symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Several improvements remained evident 14 months after treatment began.
The study provides evidence for an approach long advocated by the Hearing Voices movement: that recovery does not necessarily mean eliminating voices, but changing how people understand and relate to them.
A different approach to hearing voices
Talking with Voices is based on the understanding that voices can have personal meaning and may be connected to people’s life experiences, relationships and traumatic events.
Rather than automatically treating voices as meaningless symptoms of psychiatric illness, the therapy encourages people to explore their experiences and develop a different relationship with the voices they hear. This can involve therapists facilitating direct dialogue with voices, helping participants understand what their voices may represent and addressing the emotions and experiences associated with them.
The approach draws on principles developed and promoted by the Hearing Voices movement, which has challenged conventional psychiatric understandings of voice hearing for decades. Central to this perspective is the recognition that hearing voices is not necessarily, in itself, a problem requiring medical intervention. Instead, the focus is on understanding why some voices become distressing, threatening or disruptive, and how people can regain control over their lives.
Significant improvements in personal recovery
The study was conducted across four NHS sites in the UK, with participants randomly allocated to receive either Talking with Voices alongside treatment as usual or treatment as usual alone. The intervention involved up to 26 therapy sessions over eight months, with outcomes assessed at eight and 14 months.
The researchers selected personal recovery as their primary outcome measure, rather than focusing exclusively on symptom reduction. Personal recovery encompasses factors such as hope, autonomy, identity, empowerment and the ability to live a meaningful life, whether or not unusual experiences continue.
At eight months, participants receiving Talking with Voices demonstrated significantly greater improvements in personal recovery than those receiving usual care alone, with a moderate treatment effect. Although the difference between groups was smaller at 14 months, the improvement in personal recovery remained statistically significant.
Challenging conventional approaches
The findings represent an important contribution to a growing evidence base supporting psychological and trauma-informed approaches to distressing voices.
For decades, the Hearing Voices movement has argued that recovery need not depend on making voices disappear. Instead, understanding their meaning, exploring their relationship to personal experiences and developing less distressing ways of relating to them can be central to recovery. The new study lends scientific support to aspects of this approach, demonstrating that a structured intervention centred on engaging with voices can improve outcomes that matter to people experiencing them.
The findings challenge the assumption that reducing or eliminating psychiatric symptoms should always be the principal measure of successful treatment. They also strengthen the case for making approaches informed by lived experience more widely available within mental health services.